Saturday, November 21, 2026

Dunham: 17 states have botched executions, 14 of them on multiple occasions

Robert Dunham writing on Substack for the Death Penalty Policy Project:

Reinaldo Dennes’s execution is just the latest instance of government incompetence and deception — with a helping of misconduct often sprinkled in — in carrying out the death penalty. According to the deliberately conservative account on the Death Penalty Information Center’s Botched Executions webpage, states have botched at least 66 executions. The DPIC list doesn’t include the firing squad execution of Mikal Mahdi in South Carolina in which he bled to death after the state’s shooters largely missed his heart. Nor does it include the case of Charles Warner in which the Oklahoma Department of Corrections obtained the wrong drug but, unlike the scheduled but aborted execution of Richard Glossip, actually carried out the execution.

The botched executions on the DPIC list (including the South Carolina firing squad case as a botch) reveal an astonishing breadth of incompetence. The list reveals that seventeen different states have botched executions. Fourteen states have botched multiple executions. Seven states have botched multiple methods of execution. Alabama has botched three different methods of execution. Texas, the nation’s most prolific executioner, tops the botched execution list with at least a dozen documented botches.

Five states have halted executions in progress: Alabama, has three failed executions; Ohio and Tennessee, two each; and Idaho, one. A ninth execution, that of Oklahoma death-row prisoner Clayton Lockett, was halted midstream after the IV line exploded, blood spurted from the incision point in Mr. Lockett’s groin, and in the words of Oklahoma prison director Robert Patton, there was “a vein failure in which the chemicals did not make it into the offender.”⁷ Corrections personnel closed the curtains in the execution chamber and the eyewitnesses did not know whether Mr. Lockett was alive or dead. Mr. Patton reported that Mr. Lockett’s vein had “blown” and that, 43 minutes after the execution began, he had died from what “appears to be a massive heart attack.”⁸

Though not technically “botches,” at least five more executions have been halted at or close to the last minute because of states’ non-compliance with their execution protocols, problems with execution drugs, and/or misconduct in obtaining the drugs.

·        In Georgia, Kelly Gissindaner’s scheduled execution was halted on March 2, 2015 when the drugs the state intended to use to execute her were cloudy and contained floating particles.

·        In Oklahoma, Richard Glossip’s execution was canceled on September 30, 2015 after Gov. Fallin was notified that the state had obtained the wrong drug.

·        In Tennessee, Gov. Bill Lee called of the execution of Oscar Smith on April 21, 2022 after learning that corrections personnel had failed to test execution drugs for possible contaminants, in violation of the state’s execution protocol.

·        In Nevada, a state trial court enjoined the scheduled execution of Scott Dozier on July 11, 2018 after finding that prison officials had obtained midazolam from the pharmaceutical manufacturer Alvogen, Inc. through “subterfuge,” in violation of the company's drug distribution policies. Three years later, on June 28, 2021, a federal district court stayed the execution of Zane Floyd in response to allegations by the drug manufacturer Hikma Pharmaceuticals that state corrections officials had obtained ketamine from the company despite knowing that the drug manufacturer’s distribution policies prohibited the use of its medicines in executions.

Including these cases, there have been more than seventy — and this is an understatement — highly problematic execution attempts.

It is sometimes said that focusing on issues related to execution methods is a red herring that diverts attention from the existential question of whether there should be a death penalty in the first place. There is certainly merit to that criticism. Perseverating on executions does nothing to redress the racial and geographic disparities endemic to capital punishment, the systemic refusals to provide adequate representation, the rampant prosecutorial misconduct, the fact that more than 200 innocent people have been exonerated from death row but dozens more have been wrongfully executed, or any of the other significant failures that have created an irremediably broken policy. Nevertheless, the execution botches highlight a common and consistent thread that runs through virtually every death penalty issue: can our governments, state or federal, be trusted with this policy?

That circles us back to the beginning of this discussion. When it comes to the death penalty, government incompetence, misconduct, and lack of judgment is omnipresent. Texas’s botch of Reinaldo Dennes’s execution is just the latest instance of incompetence and prevarication. And as long as there is a death penalty, it won’t be the last.

To read more CLICK HERE

No comments:

Post a Comment